Four Formulas, One Sign Rule
Figure 1 — The three co-family results and the sign rule that produces two of them. The amber cards are the ones that carry a minus, and each corresponds to a name beginning with co-.
Reviewed by ACEpath AP Math Editorial Team
Last Updated: September 2026
30-second summary
Four formulas complete the trigonometric set: dxdtanx=sec2x, dxdcotx=−csc2x, dxdsecx=secxtanx, and dxdcscx=−cscxcotx. The signs are not random. Both co-functions carry a minus, and the two that remain positive do not. Each formula pairs a function with a companion: the tangent's derivative is a secant squared, and the secant's derivative is a secant times a tangent. None of the four needs to be memorised if you can rewrite the function in sines and cosines and apply the quotient rule, and that fallback is available on every problem that uses them.
Figure 1 — The three co-family results and the sign rule that produces two of them. The amber cards are the ones that carry a minus, and each corresponds to a name beginning with co-.
| Function | Derivative | Sign | Domain restriction |
|---|---|---|---|
| tanx | sec2x | positive | cosx=0 |
| cotx | −csc2x | negative | sinx=0 |
| secx | secxtanx | positive | cosx=0 |
| cscx | −cscxcotx | negative | sinx=0 |
The pattern is worth stating as a rule rather than a list. A name beginning with co- produced by swapping sine and cosine inherits a minus, because the swap reverses the direction of the quotient. Names that are not co-functions carry no minus.
Each one follows from the quotient rule applied to a ratio of sine and cosine:
dxdtanx=dxdcosxsinx=cos2xcosx⋅cosx−sinx⋅(−sinx)=cos2x1=sec2x
The numerator collapses to cos2x+sin2x=1, which is the Pythagorean identity doing the work. The cotangent is the same computation with the roles reversed, which is where its minus comes from. Reconstructing one formula from scratch is a reliable way to check a remembered one.
If a formula does not come back under exam pressure, rewrite the function:
| Function | Rewrite | Derivative route |
|---|---|---|
| tanx | cosxsinx | Quotient rule |
| cotx | sinxcosx | Quotient rule |
| secx | cosx1 | Quotient rule |
| cscx | sinx1 | Quotient rule |
Every one of the four is a quotient of two functions whose derivatives you already know, so the fallback costs about thirty seconds and never fails. That matters more than memorisation, because a remembered formula with the wrong sign is worse than a derived one with the right sign.
Borrowed idea: Four functions, four formulas, and one sign rule that generates half of them. Every name beginning with co- carries a minus in its derivative. The tangent and secant pair up, since differentiating one produces the other times a companion. When a formula refuses to return, rewrite the function in sines and cosines and use the quotient rule. That route always works and never needs to be remembered under pressure. Check the domain too, because all four vanish wherever the cosine or the sine does. Write the answer in the same family the question used.
| You are asked for | Sign | Formula | Companion |
|---|---|---|---|
| dxdtanx | plus | sec2x | secant squared |
| dxdcotx | minus | csc2x | cosecant squared |
| dxdsecx | plus | secxtanx | secant times tangent |
| dxdcscx | minus | cscxcotx | cosecant times cotangent |
① Derive all four from the quotient rule in a single sitting. After the second one, the pattern stops needing to be memorised.
② Cover the table above and write the four derivatives from the sign rule alone, then check. The signs should come back before the formulas do, which is the correct order of recall.
③ Differentiate tanx twice and confirm that the second derivative, 2sec2xtanx, is positive wherever the tangent is increasing. Consistency checks like this catch a lost square.
Core Archetype (Simplest Form): Differentiate f(x)=tanx+secx.
Standard Execution:
- Term by term. dxdtanx=sec2x and dxdsecx=secxtanx.
- Assemble. f′(x)=sec2x+secxtanx.
- Factor if useful. f′(x)=secx(secx+tanx).
- Check a value. At x=0 this gives 1(1+0)=1, and the graph of tanx+secx is rising at slope 1 there.
Exam Variation (Context / Parameter Shift): A quantity is modeled by Q(t)=3cott for 0<t<π. Find Q′(t) and determine whether Q is increasing on that interval.
Solution: Q′(t)=−3csc2t. Since csc2t>0 wherever it is defined, Q′(t)<0 throughout 0<t<π, so Q is decreasing and never increasing. The minus from the co- rule is what settles the direction.
Common Traps & Failure Signals:
6D Cognitive Error Diagnosis (Where Your Thinking Broke):
MCQ 1
If f(x)=tanx, what is f′(x)?
MCQ 2
If g(x)=cscx, what is g′(x)?
MCQ 3
Which of these derivatives does not carry a built-in minus from the co- rule?
A quantity is modeled by Q(t)=3cott+2sect for 0<t<π/2, measured in liters, with t in hours.
(a) Find Q′(t).
(b) Determine whether Q is increasing or decreasing on 0<t<π/2, and justify your answer.
(c) Find Q′(π/4) exactly.
(d) A classmate writes Q′(t)=3csc2t+2secttant and concludes that Q is increasing. Identify the error and explain how a sign error changes the conclusion.
| Derivative | Sign | |
|---|---|---|
| tanx | sec2x | plus |
| cotx | −csc2x | minus |
| secx | secxtanx | plus |
| cscx | −cscxcotx | minus |
| Fallback | Rewrite as sine over cosine | Quotient rule |
Strengthen this topic with AP-style practice, or continue to next topic.
Reviewed by ACEpath AP Math Editorial Team
Last Updated: September 2026
30-second summary
Four formulas complete the trigonometric set: dxdtanx=sec2x, dxdcotx=−csc2x, dxdsecx=secxtanx, and dxdcscx=−cscxcotx. The signs are not random. Both co-functions carry a minus, and the two that remain positive do not. Each formula pairs a function with a companion: the tangent's derivative is a secant squared, and the secant's derivative is a secant times a tangent. None of the four needs to be memorised if you can rewrite the function in sines and cosines and apply the quotient rule, and that fallback is available on every problem that uses them.
Figure 1 — The three co-family results and the sign rule that produces two of them. The amber cards are the ones that carry a minus, and each corresponds to a name beginning with co-.
| Function | Derivative | Sign | Domain restriction |
|---|---|---|---|
| tanx | sec2x | positive | cosx=0 |
| cotx | −csc2x | negative | sinx=0 |
| secx | secxtanx | positive | cosx=0 |
| cscx | −cscxcotx | negative | sinx=0 |
The pattern is worth stating as a rule rather than a list. A name beginning with co- produced by swapping sine and cosine inherits a minus, because the swap reverses the direction of the quotient. Names that are not co-functions carry no minus.
Each one follows from the quotient rule applied to a ratio of sine and cosine:
dxdtanx=dxdcosxsinx=cos2xcosx⋅cosx−sinx⋅(−sinx)=cos2x1=sec2x
The numerator collapses to cos2x+sin2x=1, which is the Pythagorean identity doing the work. The cotangent is the same computation with the roles reversed, which is where its minus comes from. Reconstructing one formula from scratch is a reliable way to check a remembered one.
If a formula does not come back under exam pressure, rewrite the function:
| Function | Rewrite | Derivative route |
|---|---|---|
| tanx | cosxsinx | Quotient rule |
| cotx | sinxcosx | Quotient rule |
| secx | cosx1 | Quotient rule |
| cscx | sinx1 | Quotient rule |
Every one of the four is a quotient of two functions whose derivatives you already know, so the fallback costs about thirty seconds and never fails. That matters more than memorisation, because a remembered formula with the wrong sign is worse than a derived one with the right sign.
Borrowed idea: Four functions, four formulas, and one sign rule that generates half of them. Every name beginning with co- carries a minus in its derivative. The tangent and secant pair up, since differentiating one produces the other times a companion. When a formula refuses to return, rewrite the function in sines and cosines and use the quotient rule. That route always works and never needs to be remembered under pressure. Check the domain too, because all four vanish wherever the cosine or the sine does. Write the answer in the same family the question used.
| You are asked for | Sign | Formula | Companion |
|---|---|---|---|
| dxdtanx | plus | sec2x | secant squared |
| dxdcotx | minus | csc2x | cosecant squared |
| dxdsecx | plus | secxtanx | secant times tangent |
| dxdcscx | minus | cscxcotx | cosecant times cotangent |
① Derive all four from the quotient rule in a single sitting. After the second one, the pattern stops needing to be memorised.
② Cover the table above and write the four derivatives from the sign rule alone, then check. The signs should come back before the formulas do, which is the correct order of recall.
③ Differentiate tanx twice and confirm that the second derivative, 2sec2xtanx, is positive wherever the tangent is increasing. Consistency checks like this catch a lost square.
Core Archetype (Simplest Form): Differentiate f(x)=tanx+secx.
Standard Execution:
- Term by term. dxdtanx=sec2x and dxdsecx=secxtanx.
- Assemble. f′(x)=sec2x+secxtanx.
- Factor if useful. f′(x)=secx(secx+tanx).
- Check a value. At x=0 this gives 1(1+0)=1, and the graph of tanx+secx is rising at slope 1 there.
Exam Variation (Context / Parameter Shift): A quantity is modeled by Q(t)=3cott for 0<t<π. Find Q′(t) and determine whether Q is increasing on that interval.
Solution: Q′(t)=−3csc2t. Since csc2t>0 wherever it is defined, Q′(t)<0 throughout 0<t<π, so Q is decreasing and never increasing. The minus from the co- rule is what settles the direction.
Common Traps & Failure Signals:
6D Cognitive Error Diagnosis (Where Your Thinking Broke):
MCQ 1
If f(x)=tanx, what is f′(x)?
MCQ 2
If g(x)=cscx, what is g′(x)?
MCQ 3
Which of these derivatives does not carry a built-in minus from the co- rule?
A quantity is modeled by Q(t)=3cott+2sect for 0<t<π/2, measured in liters, with t in hours.
(a) Find Q′(t).
(b) Determine whether Q is increasing or decreasing on 0<t<π/2, and justify your answer.
(c) Find Q′(π/4) exactly.
(d) A classmate writes Q′(t)=3csc2t+2secttant and concludes that Q is increasing. Identify the error and explain how a sign error changes the conclusion.
| Derivative | Sign | |
|---|---|---|
| tanx | sec2x | plus |
| cotx | −csc2x | minus |
| secx | secxtanx | plus |
| cscx | −cscxcotx | minus |
| Fallback | Rewrite as sine over cosine | Quotient rule |
Strengthen this topic with AP-style practice, or continue to next topic.